|
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
..
.
.
.
|
P.O. Box 339, 500 Salem Avenue Extension
Fredericktown, OH 43019
Office: 740-694-0496 * FAX: 740-694-0361 * E-mail:dependablepower@gmail.com
DEPENDABLE POWER SYSTEMS
COMPARISON OF UPS TECHNOLOGIES
UPS OPERATIONAL TYPES
The operation of UPS's can be divided into two basic types:
On-line or double conversion unit and off-line or standby power
unit. The on-line type continuously changes the input AC into
DC and then converts the DC to clean regulated AC which is used
to power the load continuously. The off-line unit powers the
load from the input AC normally starting the inverter only when
the input AC is lost.
The standby power unit is a good choice when the load is not
extremely critical and when the power is relatively clean, free
from spikes, and has infrequent momentary interruptions. Since
the off-line unit requires some time to turn on, it offers little
or no protection from spikes and flickers which are passed directly
through to the load. Even a 1 millisecond transfer time will
not protect the load from damaging voltage spike. When an off-line
unit fails, the failure only becomes apparent when the unit is
required to supply backup power and does not. The most stressful
period of operation, and therefore the most likely time to have
a failure, is during the shock of starting up the unit which
is exactly the time that the unit is needed most.
The standby power unit should never be used when it is to be
powered by a backup engine-generator unit. The generator's frequency
deviations will be passed directly to the critical load or will
cause the standby UPS to operate from battery even when the generator
is up and running.
In the on-line double conversion unit by contrast, the DC bus
absorbs any input spikes, flickers, sags, surges, brownouts,
or frequency variations and continues providing clean regulated
power to the load without discharging the batteries. In a blackout,
the inverter continues to supply the load from the batteries
without having to switch on. Failures in the unit, if they occur,
will most likely occur when the AC is available and the load
will be transferred automatically to the input AC without interruption.
For the most critical loads, where loss of power or damage from
voltage spikes can result in costly down time and repair, only
the on-line UPS should be chosen.
TECHNOLOGIES
There are four basic technologies used to make UPS units:
ferroresonant, pulse width modulation (PWM), PWM/ferroresonant,
and step wave.
With the ferroresonant circuit, a 60 Hz square wave is generated
from the DC bus and supplied to the ferro transformer. The ferro
transformer generates a clean sine wave and provides the regulation,
isolation, and the current limit, making for a greatly simplified
control circuit. The power SCR's are used to turn each other
off, eliminating the commutating SCR's and reducing the power
circuit components count.
The PWM circuit generates a series of high frequency pulses that
are varied in width to form a regulated 60 Hz sine wave after
the high frequency has been filtered out. The control must also
provide a high speed current limit since any overload or substantial
nonlinear load (such as a switching power supply) will pass through
the filter and stress the semiconductors. Therefore, the control
must form the sine wave, regulate the output, and provide a current
limit circuit making for a far more complex circuit. The PWM
power circuit requires at least two commutating SCR's and two
power SCR's per phase. Each of these SCR's require a separate
drive circuit. This greatly increases the component count, thus
reducing the reliability.
In order to reduce the cost of the ferroresonant transformer,
some companies vary the pulse width of the 60 Hz wave feeding
their ferro transformer. Because the volt seconds across the
primary can remain constant and lower by reducing the pulse width
as the primary voltage increases, the amount of transformer iron
can be greatly reduced. However, this circuit requires current
limit circuitry and regulation circuitry. Because the ferro is
not hard into resonance, a voltage spike on the primary can cause
the primary to saturate, sometimes blowing fuses, and can allow
the spike to appear on the output.
In both the PWM circuits, some companies have switched to transistors,
BI-MOS's or IGBT's, again to reduce cost. Our Inverter uses the
far more reliable SCR's instead of Transistors, BI-MOS's or IGBT's.
An SCR can take a 1000% current surge without damage while these
other devices die if the current exceeds 100%. These devices
are fine for computer applications where some failures can be
tolerated.
A Dependable Power Systems ferroresonant three phase unit uses
only 4 SCR's and two drive circuits in the inverter while a PWM
uses a minimum of 12 SCR's and 12 drive circuits. A transistorized
PWM reduces the component count in small units but, in larger
systems, transistors increase the parts count because of the
required paralleling. The transistor is not as rugged as an SCR,
and is therefore, far more likely to be damaged. The step wave
unit uses a series of voltage steps to generate a stair step
wave which is then filtered to form a sine wave output. The control
circuitry is at least as complicated as the PWM control circuit.
This circuit, as with the PWM, has a much larger components count,
and therefore, a higher failure rate than the Dependable Power
Systems design. While the PWM and step wave can sometimes offer
a smaller package, lower noise, and higher efficiency at 50%
and lower loads, they also require far more complex control and
power circuits which often necessitates a microprocessor controlled
diagnostics program for trouble shooting. All this complexity
reduces the dependability of these UPS's. The PWM, PWM/Ferro,
or step wave is rated at .8pf versus the Dependable Power Systems
unity (1.0) pf, i.e. a 25 KV A PWM is only a 20 KW unit, where
as a 25 KV A Dependable Power Systems unit is rated at 25 KW.
This means that a PWM or step wave unit must be oversized by
20% to be equivalent to our unit in real power output. This requirement
to oversize PWM and step wave units for high power factor applications
can more than offset their somewhat higher efficiency at partial
loads.
Many companies have gone to great lengths to obscure what technology
approach they are using. We are very competitive when all the
facts are known to the customer!
|